Disney World dining · 19 compared
The highest-rated sit-down pick of the 19 Italian restaurants SupaPark tracks is Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria (7.6/10 SupaPark Rating, EPCOT), followed by Mama Melrose's Ristorante Italiano (6.9/10, Hollywood Studios · Grand Avenue). 4 of the 19 have enough guest reviews to rate; the rest are compared on location, price and booking below.
Data as of Oct 12, 2026, 6:21 PM ET. Source: SupaPark restaurant catalog, Disney's posted menus and SupaPark availability measurements.
Disney Springs and EPCOT's Italy pavilion each have a cluster of sit-down Italian restaurants a short walk apart, and several more are spread across the resort hotels. This page puts every Italian restaurant SupaPark tracks side by side — rating, price, how hard it is to book and what is actually on Disney's menu — so you can pick by what matters to you.
Picks are the highest SupaPark Ratings among venues with enough guest reviews (sit-down restaurants first). Everything else is in the full comparison below.
| Restaurant | SupaPark Rating | Price | Booking | On Disney's menu |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blaze Fast-Fire'd Pizza Quick service · Disney Springs Good for: budget, Families | 7.8/10 | $ | No reservations · mobile order | Menu not captured |
| Enzo's Hideaway Table service · Disney Springs Good for: adults escaping the crowds, atmosphere seekers | Not enough reviews | $$ | Reservations 9 openings seen in 30d Watch for openings | Menu not captured |
| Maria & Enzo's Ristorante Table service · Disney Springs Good for: Date night, Disney Springs evening | Not enough reviews | $$ | Reservations 6 openings seen in 30d Watch for openings | Menu not captured |
| Terralina Crafted Italian Table service · Disney Springs Good for: casual dinner, Disney Springs night | Not enough reviews | mains $21–$36 · $$ | Reservations Watch for openings | Chicken Parmesan; Spaghetti Carbonara; Breakfast Pizza |
| Pizza Ponte Quick service · Disney Springs Good for: budget, Kids | Not enough reviews | mains ~$9 · $ | No reservations | See menu |
| Restaurant | SupaPark Rating | Price | Booking | On Disney's menu |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tony's Town Square Restaurant Table service · Magic Kingdom Good for: Comfort food, Families | Not enough reviews | $$ | moderate to book 949 openings seen in 30d Watch for openings | Menu not captured |
| Restaurant | SupaPark Rating | Price | Booking | On Disney's menu |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria Table service · EPCOT Good for: Big groups, Families with kids | 7.6/10 | mains $25–$39 · $$ | Reservations 249 openings seen in 30d Watch for openings | Margherita Pizza (Individual); Chicken Parmesan; Carciofi Pizza (Individual) |
| Tutto Gusto Wine Cellar Table service · EPCOT Good for: Date night, quick upscale bite | Not enough reviews | $ | Check Disney for reservations | See menu |
| Tutto Italia Ristorante Table service · EPCOT Good for: Date night, Families | Not enough reviews | mains $26–$40 · $$ | Reservations 55 openings seen in 30d Watch for openings | Tiramisù; Italian Margarita |
| Pizza al Taglio Quick service · EPCOT Good for: budget, Kids | Not enough reviews | — | No reservations | Menu not captured |
| Restaurant | SupaPark Rating | Price | Booking | On Disney's menu |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mama Melrose's Ristorante Italiano Table service · Hollywood Studios · Grand Avenue Good for: AC break, Big groups | 6.9/10 | $$$ | Check Disney for reservations | Menu not captured |
| PizzeRizzo Quick service · Hollywood Studios Good for: air-conditioning break, budget meal | Not enough reviews | $ | No reservations · mobile order | Menu not captured |
| Restaurant | SupaPark Rating | Price | Booking | On Disney's menu |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pizzafari Quick service · Animal Kingdom Good for: budget, Families | 6.6/10 | mains $11–$13 · $ | No reservations · mobile order | Sausage & Pepperoni Pizza; Caesar Salad with Chicken; Pepperoni Pizza |
| Restaurant | SupaPark Rating | Price | Booking | On Disney's menu |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Il Mulino Table service · Disney resort hotel Good for: Date night, foodies | Not enough reviews | $$$ | Reservations 5 openings seen in 30d Watch for openings | Menu not captured |
| Mangino's Table service · Disney's Shades of Green Resort Good for: budget dining, Kids | Not enough reviews | $$ | Check Disney for reservations | Menu not captured |
| Ravello Table service · Four Seasons Resort Orlando Good for: adult dinner, calm breakfast | Not enough reviews | mains $21–$28 · $$$ | Check Disney for reservations | See menu |
| Topolino's Terrace – Flavors of the Riviera Table service · Disney resort hotel Good for: romantic dinner, character breakfast | Not enough reviews | $$$ | Reservations 144 openings seen in 30d When tables open | Menu not captured |
| Trattoria al Forno Table service · Disney's BoardWalk Good for: BoardWalk stays, EPCOT break | Not enough reviews | mains $22–$39 · $$ | Reservations 3 openings seen in 30d Watch for openings | Lasagna al Forno; Tomato Bruschetta; Plant-based "Bolognese" |
| Pizza Window Quick service · Disney's BoardWalk Inn Good for: EPCOT walk-back, Kids | Not enough reviews | $ | No reservations | Menu not captured |
By SupaPark Rating, Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria at EPCOT (7.6/10), then Mama Melrose's Ristorante Italiano (6.9/10). The rating is anchored on guest-review averages, so it reflects what diners report rather than what is popular to book.
Blaze Fast-Fire'd Pizza at Disney Springs has the highest SupaPark Rating among the counter-service options (7.8/10). No reservation needed.
Blaze Fast-Fire'd Pizza has the highest SupaPark Rating at Disney Springs (7.8/10). SupaPark lists 5 Italian restaurants there: Blaze Fast-Fire'd Pizza, Enzo's Hideaway, Maria & Enzo's Ristorante, Terralina Crafted Italian and Pizza Ponte.
Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria has the highest SupaPark Rating at EPCOT (7.6/10). SupaPark lists 4 Italian restaurants there: Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria, Tutto Gusto Wine Cellar, Tutto Italia Ristorante and Pizza al Taglio.
Mama Melrose's Ristorante Italiano has the highest SupaPark Rating at Hollywood Studios (6.9/10). SupaPark lists 2 Italian restaurants there: Mama Melrose's Ristorante Italiano and PizzeRizzo.
9 of the 19 take advance dining reservations (Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria, Enzo's Hideaway, Il Mulino, Maria & Enzo's Ristorante and Terralina Crafted Italian and others); 6 are counter-service or walk-up spots with no reservations; for the other 4, check Disney's site — we could not confirm their reservation policy.
Often, yes: in the last 30 days SupaPark logged reservation openings at 8 of them, most at Tony's Town Square Restaurant (949), Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria (249) and Topolino's Terrace – Flavors of the Riviera (144). A dining alert watches for the next one.
On Disney's posted menus, main courses run from about $9 at Pizza Ponte to about $40 at Tutto Italia Ristorante, before tax and tip (7 of the 19 have a posted menu we captured). Prices change; check the restaurant's page before you go.
The SupaPark Rating is a single 0–10 score per restaurant. When a venue has a public guest-review average, the score is mostly that average rescaled to 10 (80%), blended with a small reputation prior (20%). Venues without a review average get no number at all — they are marked "Not enough reviews" and listed after the rated ones, never ranked as "best".